Review Date
July 25, 2009

Overall Rating
 5 of 5

Value Rating
 4 of 5

Reviewed by: j0hn00, Shoots in the 90s

Summary:
I've played all five courses at Bethpage numerous times. The Red course is by far my favorite. The Black is way too hard and the Yellow too bland. The Blue is interesting and the Green is just okay. The courses are maintained well and the clubhouse offers great food. If I lived closer, I'd go every time I wanted to play golf. It's a great value for New York residents and even if you're from out of state, it's still worth it.

Review Date
January 21, 2009

Overall Rating
 5 of 5

Value Rating
 3 of 5

Visitors rate this review
5.00 of 5, 1 votes

Reviewed by: Tstatguy, Shoots in the 90s

Summary:
Once you try Black , you always go back.
You dont have to be in a hedge fund to play this course and the pros play the OPEN here for the 2nd time this year.
1st hole doglegs left to right, I screwed up my drive last time I was there and landed on the next course fairway to the right, didn't see any OB stakes, got onto the small green in 2.
All greens are well bunkered, pretty flat, but very fast.
2nd Hole is right to left, uphill 2nd shot to the green
Par 3 3rd slopes towards the woods in the back of the green
Beautiful par 5 4th. Look like waves of bunkers offshore coming towards you.
Long par 4 5th hole, uphill green
Straight shot to hill crest on 6th Hole then downhill.
7th Hole par 5 dogleg left to right, in the OPEN they make it a par 4.
8th Hole par 3 only water on the course.
9th Hole dogleg right to left.
LOOOOOONNNNNGGGGGG par 4 10th, keep to the right they are letting the grass grow long.
Same thing on the 11th keep to the right stay out of the grass.
Grip it and rip it over that big bunker that will gladly welcome a weak drive on the 12th.
Lots of hills and valleys on the 13th.
Par 3 14th that will swallow your ball if you land in Death valley.
LOOOOOOOONNNNNNNGGGGGG Par 4 15th with an uphill green.
16th Hole a little right to left, sometimes the left hand rough will make you humble.
17th Hole par 3 is a poke, can barely see the surface, know your yardage.
18th Hole is down then up and there are alot of bunkers.
Arrive an hour before your tee time, once before I arrived 45 minutes before my tee time cause of a back up on the LIE, lost my tee time and was charged for not showing up.
You can ONLY walk this course NO CARTS!

Customer Service:
Have gotten a little pricey since the OPENS been there, so stuff your bag with what you need.

Review Date
August 2, 2006

Overall Rating
 4 of 5

Value Rating
 4 of 5

Visitors rate this review
5.00 of 5, 2 votes

Reviewed by: colzac, Shoots in the 80s

Summary:
The Blue Course offer s a good challenge for both beginners and seasoned players. Stating out you would thing the course would play very flay. However once into it, it becomes hilly with some sharp doglegs. The play can be slow depending on the time of day you go out and the level of player in front of you. An early start for 9 holes shouldn't last longer than 2.25 hours and 18 holes should play about 4.5 hours. The grounds are well maintained and the greens are good.

Customer Service:
Cashiers are a bit cranky. Maybe because they have to wake up too early. Fridge near green was being cut and rolled during play. It was a bit distracting and I had to wait until they finished.

Similar Courses Played:
Spring Lake, Great Rock, Eisenhower Red, Bethpage Black, Yellow and Green.

Review Date
April 20, 2006

Overall Rating
 4 of 5

Value Rating
 4 of 5

Visitors rate this review
5.00 of 5, 3 votes

Reviewed by: mgm, Shoots in the 80s

Summary:
Often overlooked by those praising the Black, this is a great course at a tremendous value. Highly recommended. However, they need to move the speed of play faster, with adequate staffing. It shouldn't take six hours to play this course.

Customer Service:
Speed up play.

Review Date
September 10, 2004

Overall Rating
 5 of 5

Value Rating
 5 of 5

Visitors rate this review
5.00 of 5, 4 votes

Reviewed by: BigBoy, Shoots in the 70s

Summary:
I played each of the 5 courses and was impressed with all of them. Whatever the USGA taught the staff here has produced some of the finest and reasonably priced golf courses in the country. Back in the 60's when I was a kid you hit off a rubber mat or a patchy tee box, sand traps were never raked even if you could find a rake and overall it was still fun. I still contend that the Black is too difficult for the average golfer but does give you a perspective as to how good the pros are. Aside from the Green course which had been aerated when I was there, the fairways and greens were great on the other 4 courses.
My only grip is they did away with the cafeteria which used to serve up some of the best sandwiches on the Island and put in a fancy snooty restaurant.

Customer Service:
ok